New York: Five Delicious (and Cheap) Brunch Spots

Baked eggs for brunch
Baked eggs for brunch. Photo by meltingnoise

Ah, brunch. Here in Gotham this midday meal is as beloved a weekly ritual as the Sunday New York Times. But, as with all rituals, there is a proper way to do brunch.

Your recipe for the perfect New York brunch goes something like this: a sprinkling of ambiance mixed with a dash of patience (brunch is generally an early afternoon affair, and there is often a wait). Fold in an egg or two, and don’t forget a cup (or more) of coffee and your breakfast cocktail of choice.

It’s this last portion that can run up the bill, but we’ve scouted some of the best brunch spots in town, those brimming with enough atmosphere to keep you happy, even if the wait is long, and inexpensive enough to keep your wallet happy.

Each of our five picks folds one brunch beverage into the meal price. If you want more than one — which is not frowned upon in this town — you’re on your own…

1. Virage (118 Second Avenue, 212-253-0425) is everything you might expect from the eclectic East Village, right down to the exposed brick wall adorned with vintage European posters. Then there’s the self-described French/Italian/Middle Eastern menu, which stretches into shades of Spanish and Mexican too.

Amid the traditional benedicts and frittatas you’ll find such delicacies as a Moroccan breakfast of baked eggs with tahini sauce. The low price of $14.25 includes coffee or tea, a breakfast cocktail, and a basket of homemade breads, and leaves money left over for that decadent nutella-stuffed brioche as dessert. If only you can find the room in your stomach.

2. Cornelia Street Café (29 Cornelia Street, 212-989-9319) proves there’s one thing New York does better than brunch: the long-shot upstart turned neighborhood mainstay. This local favorite is both — oh, and did we mention the art scene? Yep, this cozy haunt is actually a West Village trifecta: What started as a teensy café is now a beautiful restaurant and bar that helped launch the likes of Suzanne Vega.

But we’re here to talk about brunch… The pre fixe gets you your coffee, beverage, and entrée, along with a baked good from another New York favorite, the nearby Amy’s Bread (three words: warm chocolate bread!). It also gets you your little piece of New York history. Now that’s worth $18, right?

3. The Smith (55 Third Avenue, 212-420-9800) is an airy, modern hotspot with tinges of nostalgia that can be seen in the black and white tiled floor and tasted in the down home comfort food (with a modern twist). Think gooey cheddar grits, crumbly biscuits and gravy, and let’s not overlook the vanilla bean French toast with caramelized bananas.

Another thing you shouldn’t miss: a trip downstairs, where a photo booth is not the only throwback you’ll see — it’s a rare restaurant in this day and age that sports black-and-white burlesque behind tiny peepholes. Note to Cheapo: the complimentary tipple (with meals $14 to $15) is included with Sunday brunch only.

4. Isabella’s (359 Columbus Avenue, 212-724-2100) is a 20-something year-old New York classic where the uptown girls and boys go to see and be seen. At this bright and breezy spot, with its patio overlooking the American Museum of Natural History, you’ll savor simple but delicious country fare, like the bacon, egg, and cheese salad, or one of their four bennys on offer (hello filet mignon benedict). On Sundays the $12 to $15 price includes coffee or tea and your choice of breakfast beverage.

5. Penelope (159 Lexington Avenue, 212-481-3800) is a small, homey space guaranteed to have an inevitable wait, but trust us; It’s worth it. With its kitchen-facing bar and its pastry case of tempting treats, the staff serves food to match the comfy setting. It’s equally inevitable that dishes named after people — like Mabel’s homemade granola or Ellie’s spinach pie — are served up with a whole lotta love.

You can have any of this yumminess (including the irresistible pumpkin waffles with baked apples) for $14, which includes your choice of coffee/tea and juice or an apple cider mimosa. It should be noted that Doreen’s sake bloody mary is sold separately, but that doesn’t mean we love her (whoever she is) and her eponymous drink any less.

Do you have any other favorite New York City brunch spots to add? Tell us in the comments below!

About the author

Suzanne Russo
About the author: Suzanne Russo thinks of herself as equal parts California Girl and New Yorker. She moved from San Francisco to New York four years ago to pursue her MA in English, and her obsession with all things New York life and history hasn’t dwindled yet. She is a freelance writer, director of the San Francisco-sponsored, New York literary pub crawl, Lit Crawl, and constant wanderer.
Posted in: New York Eating and Drinking
Related tags: , , , , ,

Cheapo Comments

5 Responses to “New York: Five Delicious (and Cheap) Brunch Spots”
  • Nicole says:

    Don’t forget Calle Ocho on the Upper West Side- they have an unlimited FREE sangria bar :)

  • Mmmmm, free sangria!

    One other thing to add: don’t forget Brooklyn! Smith Street in Cobble Hill has plenty of restaurants, diners and cafes to choose from.

  • Alisha says:

    I’d actually love to add 2 places to this list: Cafe Orlin in the East Village on St. Marks is a fab European style brunch place tucked away from all the loud touristy attractions and hot spots in the area. Plus, it’s decently cheap and really yummy. I went there that Monday after TBEX and was thoroughly pleased with my meal.

    Being a proud Brooklynite, I pick Tom’s in Prospect Heights. I live about 5mins from this place and go there far too many times. It’s a must when you’re in the area – kitschy, wonderful, friendly, cheap, delicious, authentic. I could go on, but you must go for yourself to believe the hype!

    • Pete Meyers Pete Meyers says:

      Good call on Cafe Orlin – as I recall they have some fannnnntastic pumpkin pancakes.

      And on the Brooklyn front, I’ll also toss out a few recommendations: Sue Perette on Smith Street to tap into your inner-Francophile (or Provence en Boite across the street,) the wine bar Boca Lupa on Henry Street / Warren Street is a personal favorite, and the Clover Club on Smith / Baltic Streets for tasty Bloody Mary’s and live jazz.

      Why did I just become so hungry?

  • Here’s a Web site we recently came across devoted to the subject of brunches in New York. Check out the list in the very first post of dozens of brunch spots.

    http://www.lunfast.blogspot.com/

Leave a Comment